Current:Home > Contact-usFormat of public comment meetings for Dakota Access oil pipeline upsets opponents-LoTradeCoin
Format of public comment meetings for Dakota Access oil pipeline upsets opponents
View Date:2024-12-24 00:49:10
BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — Opponents of the Dakota Access oil pipeline are taking issue with the format of private oral testimony in meetings for public comment on a draft environmental review of the controversial pipeline.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is in the midst of two public comment meetings in Bismarck, North Dakota, the first held Wednesday, the second set for Thursday. People wishing to give testimony may do so orally in a curtained area with a stenographer, or do so in writing at tables.
The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe has long opposed the pipeline due to the risk of an oil spill contaminating the tribe’s drinking water supply. The four-state pipeline crosses under the Missouri River just upstream of the tribe’s reservation.
The long-awaited draft environmental review, released in September, outlines five options for the pipeline’s fate. Those include denying the easement for the controversial crossing and removing or abandoning a 7,500-foot (2,286-meter) segment, or granting the easement with no changes or with additional safety measures. A fifth option is to reroute the pipeline north of Bismarck, which would require new state, local and federal permits.
Many opponents of the pipeline had hoped Wednesday’s meeting would have allowed them to publicly question the Corps and pipeline developer Energy Transfer, The Bismarck Tribune reported.
Joe Lafferty, a Native American activist who opposes the pipeline, poured oil and water into a cup and challenged Corps officials to take a drink.
“If it means so much to you, I want you, DAPL, Army Corps of Engineers, drink this water with oil in it and then maybe, as a Lakota I’ll consider your request,” Lafferty said. His demonstration did not count as official testimony.
Republican state Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring, who sits on a state panel that regulates oil and gas, said the meeting was a fair process.
“I heard a comment saying, ‘This is no democratic way’ -- why, I think it very much is because you get a chance to say your piece,” he said.
About 150 to 200 people attended Wednesday’s meeting, Corps spokesperson Steve Wolf told The Associated Press. About 80 people gave oral testimony, taken down by two stenographers, which Wolf said enabled the Corps to receive more comments. The Corps received about 50 written comments.
“I understand the fact that some people want to be performative and try to create some kind of a fanfare in front of an audience of people, but that’s not the spirit and intent of the law or the meeting,” Wolf told the AP. The Corps is “absolutely on the right side of the law in how we’re doing this,” he said.
Standing Rock Sioux Tribal Chairwoman Janet Alkire last month called for the draft review to be invalidated, with a new one begun and the pipeline shut down.
A virtual meeting with only tribes is set for Nov. 8. The public comment meetings should be held on the reservation, said Peter Capossela, one of Standing Rock’s attorneys. The Bismarck meetings are more convenient for corporate executives and state officials than for tribal members who live as far as 120 miles (190 kilometers) away, he said.
“If the Army Corps is genuinely interested in hearing the views of tribal members and learning about the potential environmental impacts of an oil spill at the DAPL/Lake Oahe crossing, it would have held public hearings on the reservation that’s going to be polluted by a spill,” Capossela told the AP.
Wolf said the Corps is “being as open and transparent as we can possibly be through all of this, and nobody is being excluded from anything by us.”
State government and oil industry leaders view the pipeline as crucial infrastructure and the safest method for transporting oil, rather than by rail. Officials such as North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum and U.S. Sen. John Hoeven have said they prefer the pipeline to continue operating as it has.
The public comment period ends Dec. 13. A final decision whether to grant or deny the easement is expected in late 2024.
veryGood! (224)
Related
- Prosecutors say some erroneous evidence was given jurors at ex-Sen. Bob Menendez’s bribery trial
- Shocker! No. 10 LSU football stuns No. 8 Ole Miss and Lane Kiffin in dramatic finish
- Surfer Bethany Hamilton Shares Update After 3-Year-Old Nephew's Drowning Incident
- 1 dead, 9 injured after shooting near Tennessee State University, authorities say
- Special counsel Smith asks court to pause appeal seeking to revive Trump’s classified documents case
- Bears vs. Jaguars final score: Caleb Williams, Bears crush Jags in London
- How The Unkind Raven bookstore gave new life to a Tennessee house built in 1845
- Cardi B Reveals What Her Old Stripper Name Used to Be
- Some women are stockpiling Plan B and abortion pills. Here's what experts have to say.
- 1 dead, 9 injured after shooting near Tennessee State University, authorities say
Ranking
- Everard Burke Introduce
- New Guidelines Center the Needs of People With Disabilities During Petrochemical Disasters
- Week 6 fantasy football rankings: PPR, half-PPR and standard leagues
- Ariel Winter Reveals Where She Stands With Her Modern Family Costars
- 'Serial swatter': 18-year-old pleads guilty to making nearly 400 bomb threats, mass shooting calls
- Titans' Calvin Ridley vents after zero-catch game: '(Expletive) is getting crazy for me'
- Shark Tank's Mark Cuban, Lori Greiner and More Reveal Their Most Frugal Behavior
- New York Mets vs. Los Angeles Dodgers channel today? How to watch Game 2 of NLCS
Recommendation
-
Paraguay vs. Argentina live updates: Watch Messi play World Cup qualifying match tonight
-
Idaho wildfires burn nearly half a million acres
-
SpaceX launches its mega Starship rocket. This time, mechanical arms will try to catch it at landing
-
It’s Treat Yo' Self Day 2024: Celebrate with Parks & Rec Gifts and Indulgent Picks for Ultimate Self-Care
-
Amtrak service disrupted after fire near tracks in New York City
-
Head and hands found in Colorado freezer identified as girl missing since 2005
-
Profiles in clean energy: Once incarcerated, expert moves students into climate-solution careers
-
Indigenous Peoples Day celebrated with an eye on the election